How To Report A Claim

Most of our insurance carriers operate a 24/7 Claim Reporting Hotline. Reporting your claim directly to the carrier ensures the most rapid response for starting the claims process.

Property & Casualty

  • Erie Insurance Group800-367-3743
  • Highmark Casualty800-328-5433
  • J.C. Taylor800-345-8290
  • Ohio Casualty Insurance Co866-255-5530
  • Philadelphia Insurance Co800-765-9749
  • Progressive Insurance800-274-4499
  • Westfield Insurance Co866-937-2663


Health & Benefits

  • Aetna Insurance Co800-323-9930
  • Capital BlueCross866-686-2242
  • Guardian800-753-8208
  • Health America Insurance Co800-788-8445
  • Highmark Blue Shield800-345-3806
  • United Healthcare800-414-9961


Or, you can call your Susquehanna Insurance agent 24/7 at 717-290-7780
or 800-826-2579.